These would be difficult instructions to follow even for those more familiar with owls than Bilbo. Barn owls do not hoot, but screech, for which reason they're sometimes known as 'screech owls'. Indeed, this is the only kind of owl likely to be found in Middle-earth that are given this name (there are other 'screech owls' in the Americas, but they would not be found east of the Great Sea during the Third Age). Thus a 'barn-owl' and a 'screech-owl' are actually the same kind of owl, a kind that does not in fact hoot.
So, Thorin's instructions were ambiguous at best, to the point where Tolkien considered revising this section of the story. These revisions did not find their way into print, but they would have had Bilbo cry like a night-hawk, then hoot twice like an owl. Bilbo would have been exactly as confused by this new set of instructions as in the original version, but Thorin's intended meaning is at least easier to discern.
|